Premiere Particulars: True Detective


So I usually try to address TV premieres very soon after the original air date, but I’m a little late on this one…heck, it premiered a month ago; “late” is putting it politely. Basically, I hadn’t even heard about this show until I started seeing positive reviews for it, and now that I finally decided to check it out, here we are—four episodes in. Whoops. Haha. But I figure there’ve gotta be other folks like me out there who are tardy to the party, so for those people and for anyone else interested, here are the particulars of HBO’s True Detective.


What I liked:

  • The cool opening sequence. HBO is always great about picking the perfect songs/images to accompany the opening credits. No exception here.
  • Woody Harrelson. Personally, I think the guy’s great, and I’ve loved him in everything I’ve seen him in. Here he plays likeable Louisiana detective Martin Hart—a character in stark contrast to his somewhat odd partner, played by…
  • Matthew McConaughey. I’m more used to McConaughey in lighthearted roles (I haven’t seen Mud or Dallas Buyers Club), so it’s an adjustment to see him as Rust Cohle, an intense, overly dedicated detective who seems to live in his own headspace. But the character is fascinating, and McConaughey’s performance is brilliant.
  • The relationship between Hart and Cohle. It’s almost like a very dark Watson-Holmes relationship—Hart is the family guy who’s good with people while Cohle is more aloof, yet brilliant and even a little philosophical. However, it’s a very tense partnership, and I’m interested to see how it evolves as they continue working together.
  • The two time periods. Most of the action involves a peculiar murder in 1995, but woven into the story are 2012 interviews with Hart and Cohle, who are apparently no longer partners at this point (which ought to be an interesting story). At the end of the episode, the detectives interviewing them reveal an intriguing tidbit that tie the two time periods together and leave room for plenty of questions.
  • This show made me want to keep watching. It’s engrossing, and I already can’t wait to see what happens next.

true detective

What I didn’t like:

  • True Detective is a very dark, heavy show. Honestly, the first episode is so well done that this aspect didn’t bother me so much, but I’m listing it under “didn’t like” because the heaviness might make it less accessible to some people. You may have to be in the right mood before diving into this one.
  • Cohle is brilliant and fascinating, but he’s also kind of an a-hole—especially in the 2012 scenes. Let’s just say he has some problems. If you’re not keen on anti-heroes, you might not be keen on Cohle.
  • So this episode involves a human corpse with antlers attached to it, and because of those antlers I simply could not stop thinking about another excellent crime drama, Hannibal. The two shows are very different, of course, but Hannibal also utilizes antlers and dead bodies, which makes the corpse in this episode seem a tiny bit derivative.
  • I was under the impression that Hart was a nice guy until…well, I won’t say. You might not even catch it if you watch the episode, but I did. He’s not as squeaky clean as you might think, which is kind of shame. Cohle has enough problems—can’t Hart just be okay?!

The Potential: It seems a bit silly to assess the potential when this show is four episodes in and receiving so much acclaim…Nonetheless, True Detective’s potential is huge. There are already lots of interesting threads attached to a compelling story, and the two lead actors are absolutely great. Personally, I can’t wait to see what happens next.

My Grade: A

How about it, True Detective fans? Do I have lots to look forward to? Do you like what the show has done so far? Also, I’ve been meaning to look this up, but I’ll just be lazy and ask: is this just a miniseries, or are they hoping to have more seasons? Anyway, DON’T FORGET: tomorrow is Valentine’s Day! Go buy chocolates or flowers or something for a person you like/love/tolerate. Or buy yourself a pint of ice cream and catch up on Netflix. No shame. Personally, I plan to do something similar to the latter. Just replace “a pint of ice cream” with “a heap of McDonald’s French fries” and replace “catch up on Netflix” with “pretend to be Batman while playing Arkham City.” …Don’t judge me.

28 thoughts on “Premiere Particulars: True Detective

  1. VERY NICE, LADY!!!!! I agree with Joseph that this should be an A+++ – i think it’s one of the best shows I’ve ever seen. Screw Arkham City – you need to get caught up on this right away!! Just wait til the ends of EPs 3 and 4….

  2. Glad you started watching it, it is truly the best show in television at the moment, and may even going down in history at one of the top. Providing the final four episodes are just as good as the first four. Near perfect quality every single time. I fell in love….

  3. started watching the first episode and didn’t like it at all, so I turned it off. Does this review mean I should try another go at it?

    french fries and Batman sounds like a fun day to me. Enjoy it!

    • Haha thanks, Rob! You might give True Detective another shot. It’s a little slow at first, very grim, and Cohle isn’t the most likeable guy, but it’s also just really well done. Not for everyone, I suppose, but I’d at least finish the first episode!

  4. Good to see a post on this show, I’ve been really really curious about seeing two heavyweights in McConaughey and Harrelson going to T.V. Sounds like it’s something I need to catch up on too, because I had no idea it debuted in January!!! Yikes. 🙂

      • I’m also a little irked because it’s an HBO show, and my cable package is already expensive enough without the extras. . .so I’ll have to wait even longer I guess. . .but yeah, shows keep creeping up on me. Been intending to get to The Following and The Blacklist for some time

        • I don’t have HBO either…I just piggyback off of a friend’s HBO Go account. Shhh don’t tell! Haha. I’ve heard great things about The Blacklist, but I actually tried getting into The Following once and I didn’t really care for it. There are just too many shows! Lol.

  5. I have been watching since the first episode – and I was totally in love from the get go. There’s far more questions than answers and THAT keeps me watching. But I was a little thrown by episode 4. Is it just me or did anyone else feel like they were suddenly watching a different show? I think I need to re-watch because it could be just me. Anyway, loved reading and thanks for writing!

  6. This show is pretty awesome, but that last episode was something of brilliance. Surely it wasn’t filmed in one, continuous-shot like it was presented to us, but still, the way in which they had us believe that it could definitely be so, still amazes the hell out of me. Nice post, Cara!

  7. Pingback: Day 9, 10 and 11 – Zero to Hero: 30 Days to A Better Blog |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s