Resolutions 2014: Cool Hand Luke

cool hand luke

Hiya, kids! So after taking some time to meddle with things over at The IPC yesterday (see the mayhem here), we are now back on track with Resolutions 2014! It makes me sniffle to say this, but today’s review is actually the last of the guest reviews. 😦 Don’t get too sad though–I’m sure I’ll do this again next year (how could I not?), and I’m hoping to do another series perhaps as early as March…but I’ll share those details later. For now, we have Brian from Hard Ticket to Home Video here to finish off the guest reviews. I’m sure you follow HTTHV, but if you don’t for some reason, change that. It’s a hilarious and awesome movie blog. Here’s Brian’s take on Cool Hand Luke!

Cool Hand Luke (1967)

*spoilers throughout*

Starring: Paul Newman, George Kennedy, Strother Martin, Harry Dean Stanton, Dennis Hopper

Directed by: Stuart Rosenberg (The Amityville Horror; The Pope of Greenwich Village; The Laughing Policeman)

Synopsis: A lovable misfit commits a small crime and gets two years at a road crew prison. Beatings, egg eatings, and escape attempts ensue.

Best part: There are two amazing things about this scene: George Kennedy’s acting and some grade-A ditch digging. I mean just a fine job there, fellas.

Worst part: The whole eating 50 eggs scene is just kind of senseless. It’s fun I guess, and has become somewhat of a classic scene, but it’s just really unnecessary, and those 10 minutes could have been used on some character development.

Best line:

Nudity: The soapy cleavage seen above and a couple of inmate asses.

Overall: Paul Newman is my favorite actor by far yet I’d never seen one of his most iconic performances in Cool Hand Luke. I went into this with the expectation of loving it, but it fell a little short of that. Paul Newman was great, and George Kennedy was surprisingly outstanding, but I thought the direction was lacking throughout most of it, and there just wasn’t enough character development, even for Luke. We never really got to learn anything about any of the secondary characters, even Kennedy’s Dragline, who has almost as much screen time and dialogue as Luke. The always-excellent Strother Martin was also left with no character development or backstory, even though his character could have been even more classic than for just being known for his “failure to communicate” line. Even the “evil” prison guard who doesn’t speak never really does anything all that cruel and seemed like a wasted opportunity. In fact, the only true “unfair” thing that happened to Luke was when they put him in the box after his mother died. Other than that, it seemed like they treated everyone ok. That’s why I wasn’t entirely sure why Luke tried to escape. He was only serving two years. Just keep your mouth shut and do your time. But I suppose that wouldn’t have been much of a movie. But then they could have at least given him a little more motivation to escape. There should have been much more buildup to it. All of a sudden, he was escaping. I guess it was just because he was a “free spirit.” This movie reminded me of One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest in a lot of ways: rebellious lead, peculiar inmates, cruel administration, escape attempts, etc. But I think I prefer Cuckoo’s Nest to this, because the characters are more fleshed out. Plus Cuckoo’s Nest had a cool score, and Cool Hand Luke’s score, by TV maestro Lalo Schifrin, sounds pretty terrible, and way too “TV.” That was the problem I had with the direction as well. This was the director’s first feature after years of doing TV, and it shows. The boxing scene, for example, is horribly shot. It just could have been done so much better. So while I did like the movie very much, mostly because of Newman, I think it doesn’t quite reach all-time classic status. But maybe it just didn’t communicate its message to me the way it should have.

Score: 8 nights in the box (out of 10)

Thanks, Brian, for an excellent review! Sadly, this is yet another one I haven’t seen. More to add to my list! I’m going to give a proper thanks tomorrow, but for now let me just give a giant THANK YOU to all of you beautiful guest bloggers. You have made this series 1,000 times more awesome than I imagined, and I am eternally grateful. YOU ROCK!!! I’ll be back tomorrow for one last resolution. See you then! 😀
Advertisements

26 thoughts on “Resolutions 2014: Cool Hand Luke

  1. Hmmm… you struggled to get the message. I guess what we have here is a failure to…

    OK, I need to stop going for the obvious joke. Great review though. I love this movie, mainly because of Paul Newman. My parents actually named me after the character, so I have a personal biased love for this film.

  2. Great review, Brian. I haven’t seen this either. I’m not in any hurry to change that after reading this. Though I’m not taking it off the list, either.

    And Cara, how many times do I have to tell you this? You are the one who is awesome!

  3. Great review Brian

    This is a pretty good movie. Haven’t seen it in close to 20 years and don’t have much interest in seeing it again. Love how Guns and Roses used quotes from this for their song “Civil War”

  4. I had to watch this movie in high school and I didn’t think it was too bad. I’ve never felt like giving it a re-watch though.

    On a side note, Cara I certainly haven’t been watching you through your window again but could you please put a new lightbulb in that lamp over in the corner??? THX.

  5. The egg scene is much needed and has a a lot to do with the story. It establishes Luke’s determination and integrity, which the whole movie is about. The egg scene is not famous just because he eats all these eggs, it is also famous because of the relevance it has to the film itself. I really can’t believe you guys are not seeing this. I’m starting to worry about our future critics.

    • You’re starting to worry about future critics? I’m starting to worry about your future posting privileges on my blog…Seriously, Daniel, I asked nicely before, and I’ll ask again: please don’t talk down to reviewers on my blog. You can disagree with their opinions, but you don’t have to be rude in the process. I can’t tell–maybe you’re trying to be funny? Maybe you’re kidding? Or maybe you’re just trolling. Either way, strike two.

  6. I think I’m one of the generation who grew up listening to GNR’s Civil War and only later realized the quotes were taken from here. Definitely on my to-see list – though whenever I see George Kennedy I can’t help but think of The Naked Gun!

  7. Looks like a decent enough film. Heard a lot about Paul Newman, but have not seen a lot of him, as his peak popularity was before my time. Although I do have major interest in watching Road to Perdition, which also stars Jude Law and Tom Hanks.

    Sad to see tomorrow is the last day, but hey, it was amazing while it lasted. Good job Cara at putting it together!

  8. It’s been years since I saw this one. Probably time for a revisit. It’s one of my mom’s favourites… and she’s a bit of a free spirit.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s